Etsy's updated Terms of Use, which take effect on December 16, say Etsy and its "third party partners and vendors" may use sellers' content to develop, train, test and improve artificial intelligence, according to Engadget(opens in a new tab). Startup Fortune(opens in a new tab) lists what that content covers: listing photos, descriptions, videos, reviews and community posts. Longtime sellers walked out. Illustrator Aaron Millard deleted the shop he ran for nearly a decade, and the owners of Cognitive Surplus closed a 13-year-old store, Shopifreaks(opens in a new tab) reports. On Friday Etsy told The New York Times it will revise the terms and send sellers the new version soon.
Etsy's own account is narrower than its clause. In a forum post(opens in a new tab), James Ossman, Etsy's VP of Customer Operations, says Etsy does not train AI models designed to copy sellers' original work, and that its terms prohibit scraping Etsy to train AI. He says seller content feeds automatic translation, marketing, and seller tools such as listing optimization. He also says some vendors with Etsy's permission can reach that content, including fraud detection and advertising partners. The post calls the update a clarification and does not mention an opt-out. Startup Fortune reports that the terms point to opt-out rights in Etsy's Privacy Policy and, citing Cybernews and Value Added Resource, that there is no switch in account settings.
For anyone earning on Etsy, a listing is two things at once: the shop window that sells the item, and a body of photos and writing the seller paid for in hours. A training clause hands over a use right for that work with no price attached. What Etsy offers back is tooling: translation into other markets and help writing listings. Whether that trade is fair depends on what you sell. A furniture maker loses little if a model learns from a photo of a table. An illustrator, a photographer or a pattern designer sells the image itself, and the promise not to build copying models is Etsy's word in a forum post, not yet language in the contract that binds its partners.
Leaving has a price too. A seller who closes gives up the buyers who find them through Etsy, so closing in protest swaps one cost for another. The useful move is to judge the revised wording, not the outrage.
If you sell on Etsy, and above all if you sell art, illustration, photography or patterns, save a dated copy of the current terms this week. When the revised version arrives, check three things: whether "partners and vendors" is narrowed, whether the promise not to train copying models is written into the terms, and whether you get an opt-out you can switch on yourself rather than an email to a privacy officer. Make your stay or go decision after that, and before December 16.
Action items
Etsy's new Terms of Use let Etsy and its partners train AI on seller content from December 16. Longtime sellers closed their shops, and on Friday Etsy told The New York Times it will revise the terms and send sellers the new version soon.
Etsy says it does not train models designed to copy sellers' work. That promise sits in a forum post, not yet in the contract, and the post does not mention an opt-out.
If you sell on Etsy, save a dated copy of the current terms this week. When the revised version arrives, check whether "partners and vendors" is narrowed, whether the no-copying promise is in the terms, and whether you can opt out yourself. Decide whether to stay after that, and before December 16.
Researched and drafted by an automated workflow, then reviewed and edited by a human editor before publication. Every source is linked. See how we use AI here.
Also worth knowing
- ShopifreaksEtsy says it will revise its new terms after longtime sellers quit over a clause letting its partners train AI on their work(opens in a new tab)
Etsy told The New York Times it will revise terms that take effect December 16 and send sellers the new version soon. Longtime sellers, one with a 13-year-old shop, have already closed. Read the new wording before you decide.
- EngadgetEtsy says it will not use sellers' content to train AI after they revolt over policy changes(opens in a new tab)
Etsy's James Ossman says seller content feeds translation, marketing and seller tools, not models built to copy your work, and that fraud detection and other partners can access it. His post does not mention an opt-out.
- ABC News (AP)Senate approves bill to speed up permitting reviews, force data centers to pay for energy costs(opens in a new tab)
Passed 62 to 33 with 15 Democrats, the bill speeds permits for power plants and transmission lines and would make data centers pay for the energy they use. It now goes to the House. CFOs should watch whether those costs reach cloud and colocation prices.
- Android CentralGoogle just made its best Gemini agent free: here's where you can get it(opens in a new tab)
Tasks, formerly Spark, runs multi-step jobs in the background and no longer needs AI Pro or Ultra in the US, Canada, Japan, South Korea, Australia and India. Business calls, Google Pay checkout and sign-in start in the US, and it asks before buying.